Category Archives: Arab Revolutions

Egyptian Hypocrisy: Liberals Want the Army to Do what the Army Did not Do to Them in 2011………

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“As pressure mounts on Egypt’s military-backed interim government to forcibly disperse supporters of ousted president Mohammed Morsi from their massive sit-ins, some of the loudest, most passionate voices calling for security forces to clear the encampments come from liberals here. Liberal commentators, activists and politicians — on-state controlled media and across a spectrum of independent channels — are saying that it is long past time to evict the tens of thousands of Morsi supporters and Muslim Brotherhood backers from their sit-ins around Cairo University and the Rabaa al-Adawiya mosque……………..”

Egypt’s liberals have come along way from their “revolutionary” days of two years ago. I mean both types of liberals: the pro-Mubarak felul liberals and the former rebels against Mubarak (probably including leaders of the new tamarrod movement that was led by the UAE shaikhs). Now they want the Egyptian army to do to protesting Islamists at Rab’a what it would not do in 2011 at Tahrir. What many of them did not want it to do in 2011 during the Tahrir protests. They want the military to crush the pro-Morsi protests, something they did not want the military to do when they, the liberals, or many of them, were occupying Tahrir Square to make their (legitimate) political demands.
That is “nifaq”, spelling h-y-p-o-c-r-i-s-y in the Egyptian dialect of Arabic. Actually in all dialects of Arabic, from Morocco to the Comoros.


Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




Gangs of Aleppo: Butch Baathist and the Sundance Salafi…………

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“Rebel fighters often seize aid trucks, taking some or all of the supplies, and government forces often close roads, blocking off entire towns. About half of the grassroots humanitarian aid groups in Aleppo have stopped operating amid security threats, volunteer shortages, and a lack of resources, says Lawrence, a Syrian who asked to use a fake name and works with the organization whose clothing drive was bombed………… A year after fighting erupted in Aleppo, the city and surrounding rural districts have been hit hard by shortages, violence, and crime. Fear and uncertainty are pervasive as those who remain struggle to provide for their families. With the war in a stalemate, those living in Aleppo and the province have settled into an uncomfortable routine punctuated by government attacks and have tried to go about their lives…………………. While violence and fighting in Aleppo are down compared to last summer, according to most residents, artillery, airstrikes, and clashes remain a daily part of life. And in addition to the violence between opposition and regime forces, many residents say they worry about the continued rise in criminal violence……………… The Assad government controls less than half of the city, and the remainder is under opposition control. Civilians are able to cross between both sides of the city at designated checkpoints, but crossing is dangerous. Those who cross often must pay bribes to soldiers on both sides and risk getting caught in the middle of skirmishes……………“The good FSA are at front lines, and the bad ones are among people in the neighborhood equipped with their weapons. The bad ones kidnap or steal,” he says. Throughout Syria there are now at least 1,200 different armed opposition groups, making it difficult to determine who is a legitimate fighting group and who is a criminal gang….……….….”

It is just the normal evolution of how things started in Syria. From initial spontaneous protests, a promising start to an uprising, to a movement hijacked by Islamists and Gulf Salafists and Saudi money and Al-Qaeda affiliates. Now some of them have split off into kidnappers, thieves, and blackmailers, good old-fashioned gangsters. The metamorphoses continue. Almost predictable.
Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




Lasting Sectarian Legacy of Mubarak and the Muslim Brotherhood……

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“When Hosni Mubarak ruled Egypt, Ahmed Helal was locked up four times in Tora prison, officials’ favorite detention facility for perceived enemies of the state. Each time, he was arrested in the middle of the night and thrown in with scores of others whose only offense, they believed, was being Shiite Muslims…………. In the year that recently ousted President Mohamed Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood held power, the threats grew graver. Brotherhood officials denounced Shiite practices and declared that the sect had no place in Egypt. Lawmakers pushed through a new constitution that made Sunni religious doctrine the basis for most laws. One young preacher who converted to Shiism was jailed on charges of insulting Islam. The trouble culminated in a gruesome lynching in a village outside Cairo in June, when a mob dragged the bloodied bodies of a prominent Shiite cleric and three others through the streets while police officers stood by……………….”

I am afraid this sectarian legacy built during the years of both Hosni Mubarak and Morsi will continue no matter who rules in Cairo. Under Mubarak Shi’as were persecuted, prevented from practicing their rites and often imprisoned for who they were. That was the effect of thirty years of continued Wahhabi influence over the once tolerant and accepting Egyptian society.
The Islamist regime that was freely elected brought to power a coalition of Muslim Brothers and Salafis, which institutionalized the persecution of Shi’as (and the Christian Copts and other minorities). It made it halal and kosher to openly spout sectarian hatred. Even some of Egypt’s self-proclaimed liberals got into the habit of doing so.
I suspect that the treatment of Shi’as will not get much better under any regime in Egypt in the near future. There are institutional and political factors now that will push for its continuation: from the Mubarak bureaucracy to the Al-Azhar bureaucracy to the influential Salafis to the Persian Gulf princes and potentates. It took thirty one years for Egypt to reach the stage where people got lynched in public for their faith while the police watched. It may take at least another generation to return Egypt to its tolerant past. Maybe.

Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




General Dempsey and the War Experts: Swedes to Liberate Syria.…………

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“Several international defense experts said that a recent letter from America’s top military leader about the war in Syria revealed a “great power” weary of conflict, cautious on spending and hesitant about overseas engagements. “Very risk averse” is how Magnus Ranstorp, a security expert at the Swedish National Defence College, described the recent letter to Congress from Gen. Martin Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, in which he laid out the U.S. options on Syria. “This letter reflects the dilemma the United States is facing,” Ranstorp said. “After a decade of military action, the American military knows well that it can be no more than part of a real solution.”………..”

It seems easy for others, for example some Swede, to call Dempsey “very risk averse”. I don’t see his country gung-ho on fighting in Syria. Ditto for other European hawks: they are happy to see American boys and girls go to war while they cheer over their glass of claret or aquavit or stein of beer. They like wars once-removed: the British and French governments were the most eager to have the European Union lift its arms embargo for Syrian rebels, yet now they refuse to supply arms because they have discovered that the rebels who really count are Salafi Jihadis.
FYI: low cost is not a normal justification for going to war, otherwise everybody would be invading Monaco and the Comoros. So why not let Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Sweden fight in Syria?

Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




Wages of European Jihad in Syria, Literally…….

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“Armed men from the Balkan Peninsula earn $600 per month to join Al-Nusra Front in Syria and are fighting against the Syrian army.
According to a report by Al-Alam on Tuesday, dozens of terrorists from Balkan have been killed in Syria, away from home. Moaz Sabik, one of the terrorists was killed near Aleppo, but his family were told about his death in their house in a small village near Bosnian border.
All his family knows about his death is that he was a member of a group which fought the Syrian army.
The monthly payment of the gunmen in Syria, some paid with the financial supports of human rights agencies and organizations, equals 600 dollars.
Ilias Sabik, Moaz’s brother said in an interview with Bosnian media that his brother left Sarajevo for Istanbul last March and two young men from Zenica and Kakanj accompanied him. According to local reports, Moaz was one of the 52 people who were deployed to Syria.
Reports suggest that volunteers from Bosnia gathered in Antioch and illegally crossed Bab al-Hawa to enter Syria.
Over 300 people from Balkan Peninsula, with Bosnian, Serbian, Albanian and Macedonian nationalities, are estimated to be fighting in Syria.
These volunteers gather once gain this time in Sarmada town inside Syria so that they can be trained to join the militia, the Free Syrian Army; however most of them join the Taliban-linked terrorist group, Al-Nusra front.
Extremist Salafis in Bosnia support aid-providing organizations in the Arab world, particularly Saudi Arabia, where Wahabbis and Salafis hold strong ties………………”

This is a claim by an Iranian news agency, quoting another Iranian media. Still, not bad, $600 per month for giving it a try to die for the cause and go to Paradise. It is true that if he dies too soon, he will not enjoy spending the $600 on WTF Salafi Jihadis spend money on, perhaps a wife, or another wife. Still, if he is martyred by a bullet between the eyes or by a bomb exploding under the toilet, who cares. He still has the next option of what to do in Paradise, assuming he will end up there. Of course he’ll end up there, otherwise what is the point of fighting? Anyway, it is a nice thought, until you consider that he might end down there where no angle has gone before (except allegedly for one).
Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




Jesuit Priest Paolo Dall’Oglio Murdered by Syrian Rebels?……….

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“A Jesuit missionary who was abducted in northeastern Syria in July has been killed, according to one of the country’s most prominent rebel activists. Lama al-Atassi, secretary general for the Syrian National Front, wrote on her Facebook page that Italian priest Paolo Dall’Oglio, 59, has been executed. “It’s with deep sorrow that I inform you that I was told by a reliable source that father Paolo has been executed. May God have mercy of his soul,” she wrote. The Italian foreign ministry said it has no intelligence to confirm the claim………..”

This is just one source, but she is apparently considered a “reliable” pro-rebel source.
Apparently there are still “reliable” Syrian sources on Syria, on both sides.
Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




Syrian Rebels Revive the Regional Kidnap Industry……………

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“Two Turkish Airlines pilots have been kidnapped in Beirut, in an ambush that Lebanese officials believe is linked to the capture of nine Lebanese Shia pilgrims in northern Syria 15 months ago. In response, Ankara called on its citizens to leave Lebanon and avoid travelling there, and launched an urgent round of contacts with Lebanese leaders who said they had no immediate leads as to who was responsible. The pilot, Murat Akpinar. and co-pilot, Murat Agca, were seized by six gunmen at 3.30am on Friday, less than one mile from Rariq Hariri airport in Beirut’s southern suburbs. They had been travelling to a hotel in the city in an airline-owned van after flying from Istanbul …………….”

“Syrian rebels have pushed deep into the coastal Alawite stronghold for the first time, seizing a string of villages in a campaign which, locals have warned, threatens to open the area up to full-blown sectarian war. “We are still finding people who were killed in their homes, and bodies left in bushes,” said Sheikh Mohammed Reda Hatem, an Alawite religious leader in Latakia. “Until now 150 Alawites from the villages have been kidnapped. There are women and children among them. We have lost all contact with them.”……………..”

Lebanese Shi’as. Iranian Shi’as, Christians, Alawites, 2 bishops, 2 other priests, many others. An Italian Jesuit priest activist Paolo Dall’Oglio was kidnapped this past week by his rebel hosts in Al Riqa region.
It is very likely some of the Lebanese clans who have had their members kidnapped by Syrian rebel groups along the Turkish border are using the kidnapped Turkish pilots as bargaining chips.
Suddenly kidnappers are doing a brisk business in Lebanon and Syria, but probably not enough to offset the crashing tourist industry..
Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




On the Evolution of Anti-Shi’ism…………

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“Sectarian tensions are not new, of course, but the vocabulary of anti-Shiism in the Middle East has changed dramatically over the last 10 years. Shiites who used to be accused of ethnic otherness are now being cast as outside the Muslim community itself. Exclusion on doctrinal grounds was a mostly Saudi exception in the framing of Shiism. It is now increasingly becoming the regional rule. Prior to 2003, anti-Shiism in Iraq was perhaps best encapsulated in the term ajam…………. In other words, prior to 2003, Middle Eastern Sunni-Shiite dynamics were more often manifestations of nationalistic and ethnic rather than religious expression. …………These pre-2003 niceties, superfluous as they might seem to most Shiites, have long since been discarded. While Shiites’ Arab pedigrees continue to be questioned, anti-Shiite discourse today is overwhelmingly concerned with religious otherness. It is the post-2003 sectarian landscape and the inflammation of a religiously inspired sectarian entrenchment that has shaped the sectarianization of Syria’s civil war in stark contrast to how the Hama massacre of 1982 was framed. Likewise, it is this new sectarian landscape that is facilitating Hezbollah’s unabashedly Shiite posture of late. Just as it is the post-2003 environment that has led to the spread of Sunni-Shiite tension beyond its usual geographic hotspots — who could have predicted the public lynching of Shiites in Egypt of all places? ……………………”

An interesting article in Foreign Policy magazine, but it compels me to add my own two cents.
Many
sectarian events have racked the Muslim world in recent years, stretching from Morocco to Indonesia. One of these stands in my mind as the most shocking, as an indication of the degree of sectarian hatred that has eaten the social fabric of Muslim societies
. That was a few months ago, when neighbors attacked and lynched their neighbors in a town in Egypt. When one of the previously most tolerant Arab countries witnessed thousands of Sunni Muslims converge on a house of Shi’a Muslims and basically rip them to pieces.
Saudi media, and some other Gulf media, often emphasize a sinister connection between Shi’ism and being pro-Iranian (sometimes these campaigns tend to be self-fulfilling to some extent). Other favorite terms for Shi’as once used by Baathists in Iraq and now used by despotic tribal ruling clans in Saudi Arabia and Bahrain and by Persian Gulf Salafis are: Majouss (Magi, referring to Zoroastrianism, the pre-Islamic faith of the Persian Empire); and Safawi (referring to the Safavid Shi’a dynasty of Persia which fought with the Ottoman Turks for control of what is now Iraq). Both terms seek to deliberately emphasize some perceived Persian or Iranian connection or nature of Arab Shi’as and distinguish them from other Arabs.

Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




Puzzle of Egyptian Presidents: from a Ram to a Zombie to the next Arab Ass……..

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

Egyptian have been blessed, if that term can be used here, with two unique presidents during one year:


  • The first was the elected Mohamed Morsi, whom many of his opponents called “kharoof”. Kharoof means sheep in Arabic, actually a male sheep, a ram. Being like a ram is considered a desirable quality in the West, it indicates strength and stubbornness and a distinct unequal ability to butt heads. Something Mr. Morsi clearly did, which landed him in a military prison after the military coup by the man he had appointed defense minister. But alas some of his people called him a ‘ram‘ in a derogatory sense rather than in admiration: in the Middle East, especially in the Arab world, we don’t appreciate the finer qualities of some five-legged animals. For example, being called a ‘bull‘ is considered a good thing in the West, as long as it is not in a China shop. In our region a bull is considered an insult, a sign of stupidity, which shows how stupid we can be. As for being called an ass, or a jackass or donkey, I would not want to go there, we have too many of those asses who are only willing and eager to replace the maligned rams and bulls. From the looks of things, many of these asses make it.
  • The second Egyptian president of the year is even more questionable if only because he seems invisible, even with his girth. That would be Mr. Adly Mansour, whom I correctly dubbed early on as president Adly Mansour Al Zombie. He did then and he still does look like a zombie.
  • It is not clear who the next president of Egypt will be. Will he be another kharoof (ram)? Will he be another zombie? Or will he be the usual Arab ass?

Cheers
mhg

[email protected]




GCC: Ruling Despots Ready for Massive Protests in the Repressed State of Bahrain?……

      


 Follow ArabiaDeserta on Twitter      

“The highly patriotic stand of the National Unity Assembly (NUA) was commended by the Premier. He hailed the gathering at Al Fateh Mosque, organised by the NUA at the height of the unrest, to re-emphasise their loyalty to the nation and thwart attempts of conspirators to hijack the nation. His Royal Highness Prime Minister Prince Khalifa bin Salman Al Khalifa said this as he visited the NUA headquarters yesterday. “As we foiled the conspiracy together, we have to stand together now in one trench to eradicate terrorism,” he said, urging solidarity with the government in confronting terrorism and toughening punishment on its perpetrators and instigators. He stressed the government’s resolve to carry out the will of the Bahraini people to protect society from the dangers of terrorism……………….”

Also sprach Gulf Daily News, one mouthpiece of the repressive ruling kleptocrats of Bahrain, as the people of that country get ready for more massive protests in the capital Manama on August 14. The Bahrain uprising started on February 14, 12011, and is halfway through its third year, but it is opposed by most Arab governments including those of countries that allegedly have experienced so-called uprisings and revolutions (Egypt, Libya, Tunisia). Official Arab institutions, never known for their courage or love of freedom, also side with whoever the Arab despots support and often with whoever has the money (the acronym for money would be G-C-C).

Already
, Persian Gulf potentates and their tame and controlled media are lining up behind the rulers against the people. Governments, absolute rulers, their merchant class allies, Salafi Wahhabis, tribal types, and others are calling on the regime to crush what some of them call the “terrorists“. “Terrorist” is an epithet used by the rulers and their media for most of the people of Bahrain. Even some on the Gulf who demand freedom in their own countries are opposed to the Bahraini people’s demands (it is the sectarian-tribal instinct). Even European expatriates, especially the British, are doing their bit for the side of the rulers (the absolute Shaikh of Bahrain is reported to have traveled four times to Britain this year alone and he certainly does not go to attend soccer games).

Cheers
mhg

[email protected]